Legacy ImageMagick Discussions Archive

The string format %[colorspace] is not producing correct results for grayscale images.

convert rose: -colorspace gray roseg.png

convert roseg.png -format "%[colorspace]" info:
sRGB   <---- should be Gray

and similarly

Code: Select all

convert rose: -colorspace gray -gamma 2 roseg_gamma2.png

convert roseg_gamma2.png -format "%[colorspace]" info:
RGB   <---- should be Gray

Note it was producing correct results (Gray) at IM 6.8.6.0 and changed somewhere after that but before IM 6.8.9.0

The PNG file seems ok:

Code: Select all

glenn.rp> pngcheck -v roseg_gamma2.png
File: roseg_gamma2.png (2887 bytes)
  chunk IHDR at offset 0x0000c, length 13
    70 x 46 image, 8-bit grayscale, non-interlaced
  chunk gAMA at offset 0x00025, length 4: 0.90909
  chunk bKGD at offset 0x00035, length 2
    gray = 0x00ff
  chunk IDAT at offset 0x00043, length 2702
    zlib: deflated, 4K window, maximum compression
  chunk tEXt at offset 0x00add, length 37, keyword: date:create
  chunk tEXt at offset 0x00b0e, length 37, keyword: date:modify
  chunk IEND at offset 0x00b3f, length 0
No errors detected in roseg_gamma2.png (7 chunks, 10.3% compression).

and the gamma=0.90909 makes sense:

Code: Select all

glenn.rp> dc
8 k
2 2.2 / p
.90909090
q
glenn.rp>

So the colorspace seems to be getting added while reading it
back in, in the second command. This extract from the log:

Code: Select all

Enter ReadPNGImage()
  Enter ReadOnePNGImage()
    IM version     = 6.8.8-7
    Libpng version = 1.7.0beta33
    Zlib version   = 1.2.8
    Before reading:
      image->matte=0
      image->rendering_intent=2
      image->colorspace=13
      image->gamma=0.454545
      Found PNG gAMA chunk.
      Reading PNG gAMA chunk: gamma: 0.909090

shows that the image has already been labeled as sRGB before
it begins reading the PNG datastream, but then the gamma
gets reset when the gAMA chunk is decoded.

The bug here is that later, coders/png.c checks for image->gamma==1.0 to
decide whether to reset the colorspace. I guess something
like image->gamma > 0.75 would work more like people expect.
I'll make that change.

As a minor aside, I'll comment that when I use "-gamma X" but I want the image to be treated as sRGB, I always follow this with "-set gamma 0.454545". Otherwise, image viewers that regard gamma settings don't do what I want.

Yes, it would appear to be limited to PNG.

Code: Select all

convert rose: -colorspace gray roseg.jpg
convert roseg.jpg -format "%[colorspace]" info:
Gray

Code: Select all

convert rose: -colorspace gray roseg.tif
convert roseg.tif -format "%[colorspace]" info:
Gray

Just for reference, I point out that it was producing correct results (Gray) for PNG at IM 6.8.6.0 and changed somewhere after that but before IM 6.8.9.0

Legacy ImageMagick Discussions Archive

possible bug %[colorspace] IM 6.8.8.7 Q16 Mac OSX

possible bug %[colorspace] IM 6.8.8.7 Q16 Mac OSX

Re: possible bug %[colorspace] IM 6.8.8.7 Q16 Mac OSX

Re: possible bug %[colorspace] IM 6.8.8.7 Q16 Mac OSX

Re: possible bug %[colorspace] IM 6.8.8.7 Q16 Mac OSX